Back to all recipes

Jerusalem Kugel

קוגל ירושלמי (kugel Yerushalmi), Jerusalem

🇮🇱 Israel Desserts medium 35 min prep · 2 hr cook serves 10 to 12 wedges 3 hr start to table ~340 kcal per piece surprise

A caramel-bound noodle cake loaded with enough black pepper to bite back, eaten for breakfast after synagogue. Sweet dessert noodles and hot pepper in the same dense slice, on purpose, for two centuries.

The sugar is not just melted but taken to a deep mahogany caramel, which adds toasty, faintly bitter notes instead of plain sweetness. Against that backdrop the black pepper reads as warmth rather than a mistake, and the long slow bake crisps the outer noodles while the inside stays chewy and dense.

🍝🌶️
The story

Yerushalmi kugel comes from the Old Yishuv, the Jewish community living in Jerusalem under Ottoman rule long before the modern state existed. Ashkenazi settlers, by most accounts the Perushim, disciples of the Vilna Gaon who arrived from Lithuania in the early 1800s, adapted the sweet lokshen kugel they had carried from Europe, and somewhere in Jerusalem it took on caramelized sugar and a startling dose of black pepper.

It is still made the old way in Haredi neighborhoods like Mea She'arim, often left overnight on a Shabbat hotplate so it is warm after Saturday morning prayers, and bakeries across Israel sell wedges of it on Friday mornings. Its home turf is the kiddush table after services, where the classic accompaniment is a sour dill pickle, which sounds like a second joke but balances the sweetness well.

Fair warning: The pepper heat is real and the texture is dense and slick with oil, so people expecting a soft sweet noodle casserole are often startled by their first bite.
The recipe

Ingredients

  • 450 g (1 lb) thin egg noodlesthe finest strands you can find
  • 90 ml (6 tbsp) neutral oilcanola or sunflower
  • 250 g (1 1/4 cups) sugar200 g for the caramel, 50 g for the egg mixture
  • 5 large eggsbeaten
  • 1 1/2 tsp fine salt
  • 1 1/2 to 2 tsp black peppercoarsely ground; use the full amount for the real thing

Method

  1. Cook the noodles in salted water until just tender, drain them well, and put them in a large heatproof bowl to cool slightly.
  2. Heat the oven to 175 C (350 F) and generously grease a deep 4 to 6 quart oven-safe pot or Dutch oven.
  3. Combine the oil and 200 g of the sugar in a heavy skillet over medium heat and stir constantly for 10 to 12 minutes, until the sugar dissolves and turns a deep mahogany brown, darker than feels safe but not smoking.
  4. Pour the hot caramel over the noodles immediately and toss with two forks to coat the strands; any hardened clumps will melt again in the oven, so keep tossing and move on.
  5. Let the noodles cool for about 10 minutes so the eggs will not scramble on contact.
  6. Whisk the eggs with the remaining 50 g sugar, the salt, and the pepper, then fold the mixture through the noodles until every strand looks glossy.
  7. Scrape everything into the greased pot, press the surface down lightly, and bake uncovered for about 2 hours, until the top is deeply browned and crusty.
  8. Rest the kugel in its pot for 15 minutes, run a knife around the edge, and invert it onto a plate.
  9. Cut into wedges and serve warm, ideally with sour dill pickles on the side.
Shopping notes
Everything is at an ordinary supermarket; if you cannot find very thin egg noodles, break fideo or angel hair into short lengths. A deep pot gives the traditional tall, dense kugel, but a 23 cm (9 inch) round pan works with a shorter bake of about 75 minutes.
Cross-checked against: myjewishlearning.com · thetasteofkosher.com
Kitchen notes

Cooked it? Say how it went. Tweaks, substitutions, honest verdicts, all welcome.

Loading notes...